Advertisements

Women’s News: Fat Shaming Can Lead To Weight Gain — Now Can We Stop The Bullying?

DEU Uebergewicht

The Huffington Post  |  By 

Fat discrimination and prejudice are everywhere — at work, in dating situations, inmedia (we are not over it, Rex Reed), in think tanks, in academia and on the street. (Don’t believe it? Read these women’s stories.) It persists in part thanks to the myth that this type of bullying has an admirable purpose — to shame people into losing weight.

Finally, science is echoing what body image bloggers and other advocates have said for years: shame doesn’t inspire anyone to change.

In 2006 and again in 2010, a new study, led by psychologist Angelina Sutin at the Florida State University College of Medicine in Tallahassee, Fla., collected the body mass indexes of 6,157 Americans ages 50 and over who were either normal weight, overweight or obese, Today reported. The research team found that overweight people who faced weight discrimination were over two times more likely to become obese by the end of the study. Participants who were obese when the study began and had experienced weight discrimination were three times more likely to still be obese in 2010. “Rather than motivating individuals to lose weight, weight discrimination increases risk for obesity,” Sutin summarized her findings.

Art Caplan, the head of the Division of Medical Ethics at NYU Langone Medical Center, told Today that the study is evidence that there is no easy fix for our weight issues, least of all the fat shaming that happens all the time. “Many people, from your sister-in-law to ethics professors, think that the road to weight control runs directly through shame and humiliation,” Caplan said. “Common sense says that this is not likely to be true… Obesity remains a complex problem — part choice and free will mixed in with a smidgen of genetics, sedentary lifestyles and a whole lot of promotion and advertising of fast food, sugary food, high-caloric food and junk food,” he said.

As Today and Caplan also note, it doesn’t help that at least one ethicist — a person who studies right and wrong — has encouraged fat shaming. (By way of an analogy about ageism, the ethicist in question, 83-year-old Daniel Callahan, suggested to Today that fat people imagine weight discrimination.)

What Caplan didn’t mention is the role that what National Eating Disorder Association spokesperson and The Frisky blogger Claire Mysko calls “the Diet Industrial Complex” plays in individuals’ and society’s struggle with weight.

The weight loss industry pulls in $20 billion annually, positioning itself as the solution to our weight woes, but as Geneen Roth, author of “Breaking Free from Emotional Eating,” has emphasized again and again, diets are likely part of the problem. They teach people that they don’t know how to feed themselves and that they deserve deprivation. They’re inherently shaming, and then there’s the inconvenient truth thatdiets often result in weight gain down the road.

What anyone who eats more than he or she needs and feels bad about it needs to do is tune in to exactly what she or he wants and how much. That’s the only way you learn to recognize and honor when you’re full.

Earlier this year, Mysko beautifully summed up what overweight people don’t need:

it is safe to say that a fat woman who struggles with her weight and body image will not find vicious name-calling or cruel jokes to be just the motivation she needs to stick to that magic diet (you know, the one that’s going to screw up her metabolism and make her even more likely to binge and obsess over food)

With any luck, more studies like Sutin’s and the press they receive will finally end the idea that you can shame someone thin. Not that shaming anyone for anything, no matter how justified you feel, has ever actually been okay. If you’re being mean, you’re just being mean.

Read More:  http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/29/fat-shaming-weight-gain_n_3670560.html?utm_hp_ref=women&ir=Women?utm_hp_ref=women&ir=Women

Advertisements

Comments

  1. songtothesirens says:

    Guilt and shame have never been huge motivators for me to do anything. What works is a person’s desire to better themselves be it weight, knowledge, education, whatever, and then having a good support system, and to always remember that with weight loss, especially, you will fall off the wagon when the Krispy Kremes show up at the office. But, that is a fleeting weakness, and not indicative of where your attempt is heading. In fact, it may have been a good thing that the donut got eaten. One won’t feel deprived as is so common when one is changing the fundamental way they relate to food. I believe that obesity is a combination of culture, genetics, and a person’s “relationship” to food, and a host of other factors such as medication. I say relationship because some people use food to comfort themselves like a child’s “blankie.” They have developed a dependency on food which is not healthy. These people could probably benefit from therapy in addition to exercise (no, you don’t have to train for a marathon) and fundamental diet changes.

    Just speaking as someone the medical community considers to be “mildly” obese. What is it? Am I obese, or not? All they go by are actuarial tables of the healthy weight range for a woman who is 5′ 10″ tall. They do not take into account muscle mass, bone structure, or anything but height and sex. And, to me, that’s just plain stupid. I am curvy, not “mildly” obese. Sheesh….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: